The Agony and The Ecstasy of Having a Very Popular Name, Part Two

Well, we learned a lot on Saturday.

  • I was supposed to be Amos. I would have been a hayseed with overalls, most likely. Driving a tractor.
  • There are a lot of songs with my name in the title; however, they are not all good. Or even slightly tolerable.
  • I like the name Ermentrude.
  • “Amy” is a very rah-rah-sis-boom-bah cheerleader name, and, as discussed, I am anything but rah-rah. I’m more growl-growl.

I meant to discuss what my CRITERIA were, in the last post, for what makes a very good Amy-song. But got distracted. Probably by that song where that guy said he was in a band, but it was just him, and he purported to have been making out with someone named Amy by the water but I think we can all agree no one ever made out with him willingly.

Criteria for a good Amy-song:

  • Catchy.
  • Extra points for it being romantic. (I’m a total sucker for sad songs.)
  • A song that, were someone to woo me with it, I would totally be wooed. TOTALLY be wooed. (Knowing an Amy-song is a total romantic coup with me.)
  • Says “Amy” not ONLY in the title, but in the lyrics as well.

Otherwise – well, it’s kind of nebulous. It’s tough to say what kind of song will work for me and what won’t.

So, let’s see what we have today! Ready for more Amy-songs? YAY! ME TOO!

“Amy’s Back in Austin” – Little Texas

This man has a most prodigious mullet.

This song is foolish, and I care not for it at all. It’s not good, and the story isn’t very interesting. A girl and a guy move away together but then they break up and she moves away and he misses her! Um. BORING.

Check out that mullet, though.

SIDE NOTE: I am quite desperate to visit Austin, Texas. I think Austin and I would get along very well.

Grade: C

“Amy’s Song” – Joshua Radin

(Side note: I have a huge crush on Joshua Radin. I love his voice and I think he’s utterly adorable. He was in the season finale of Cougar Town – YES, I watch that, SHUT UP, it is HILARIOUS – and he was just supposed to be some guy on the street, you weren’t supposed to RECOGNIZE him, and I was all “ZOMG JOSHUA RADIN!” and I played that part over and over about seven times.)

That being said, I don’t love this song. It’s only an Amy-song in the title, and it’s kind of annoying and a little whiny. That makes me sad. I had high hopes for this, being my man Joshua Radin and all. Sorry, Joshua Radin. I will, however, still listen to “You Got Growin’ Up to Do” over and over some days. It’s a thing I do.

Grade: B-

“Amie” – Pure Prairie League


This may well be my favorite Amy-song of all time. I discovered this on a road trip when I was in college. And I played it OVER AND OVER AND OVER. I love the twangy country of it; I love the repeated use of “Amie,” I love “I keep fallin’ in and out of love with you,” I love near the end where he sings “longer if I do, yeah, now.”

I have a friend who sings part of this to me whenever he sees me. A lot of people don’t like this person. I think possibly part of why I like him so much is that everytime I see him, I know he’s going to sing “I think I could stay with you, for a while, maybe longer if I do” to me.

I’m easily won over.

Grade: A+

“Amy’s Song” – Switchfoot

Oh, my goodness, this isn’t very good, is it? I don’t like these people’s voices and I don’t like the lyrics. I don’t know what it’s supposed to be saying. This Amy left and she left quite an impression? I guess? This is not a very good song. I’ve never heard of this band. Is anyone reading this a fan of this band? If so, can you explain to us why you’ve made this choice?

Grade: D

“Amy” – Paul Petersen

WHAT IS HAPPENING HERE. This is the kind of music a serial killer plays right before he slices your face into a permanent smile and dances around you wearing a kimono. This is…a song about a child in love with a grownup? Maybe? This singer seems to want Amy to go to jail for statutory rape. I DO NOT APPROVE OF THIS PAUL PETERSEN. Listen to how he moans “Amy” at the end. IT IS THE WORST.

(Also, check out his face on that album cover, and the titles of his other songs. “My Dad.” “She Can’t Find Her Keys.” I feel like he’s a joke singer on a Saturday Night Live skit.)

Grade: F

“Amie” – Damien Rice

(Side note: I am crazy for Damien Rice. CRAZY. I sometimes listen to his music on a continuous loop all day at work. Like, ALL DAY. If you want to woo me, play me Damien Rice. Sincerely. The love and pain and longing in this man’s voice just fills my whole chest up.)

I love this song. This is a beautiful, sad song. Like most Damien Rice songs, this is a love song where something is lost. I feel like all Damien Rice songs are about losing someone. When I’m sad over the end of something, I tend to listen to a LOT of Damien Rice. (Well, more than I usually do, which is a lot.) It’s not as good as some of his other songs – I can’t choose between “Rootless Tree,” “The Blower’s Daughter,” “Volcano,” and “9 Crimes” for my favorite Damien Rice song, because they’re all utterly the most brilliant things ever.

Grade: A

“Song for Amy” – Jack Ingram

This song is bland. If this song was a food, it would be cottage cheese. If this song was a weather, it would be sixty degrees. If this song was a television show, it would be a documentary about the production of cutlery.

Confession: I couldn’t even listen to all of this. It was putting me to sleep.

Grade: C-

“She’s No Amy” – Ryan Turner

I don’t like this very much, but it makes me sad. I feel bad for the not-Amy in this song. Because I’ve totally been the not-Amy, and I’ve been the person putting someone else through the not-Amy hoops, waiting for the Amy to come home.

Emotions are terrible things sometimes, aren’t they?

He has a nice enough voice, I suppose. And it’s not a TERRIBLE song. It’s just not the best written thing in the land. But whoo. Memories.

Grade: B-

“Amy” – Ryan Adams

(Side note: I adore Ryan Adams. He sings my favorite song of all time. There are a million billion songs in the world, and he sings the one I love most out of ALL of them. No, I can’t tell you what it is. It’s just for me. Also, he’s a talented singer and songwriter and gives an excellent concert and used to have just the best beard and you know my beard-thing.)

All of that being said, I don’t love this song. I think it’s because the BEST SONG IN THE WORLD has ruined all other Ryan Adams songs for me. This is ok, but I know he can do better, so I’m not blown away.

Grade: B+

“Once in Love with Amy” – Frank Sinatra

(Side note: A lot of other people have covered this over the years, too, but if there’s a version with my man Frank, we’re listening to it.)

This is my other favorite Amy-song. It makes me so happy. Even though it’s a little confusing. Because if you listen to the lyrics closely, it tells you all the things you can do with this Amy – kiss her and romance her and buy her things – but she’s still in love with the singer. So why is she letting these other beaus do these things with her? That seems whorey. Stop cheating on your singer, other-Amy.

Eh, no matter. I am in love with this. Sometimes I sing it to myself. Someday, someone will sing this to me, and I will be the happiest girl who ever happied.

Another side note: I found this one the YouTubes and couldn’t not post it. Because Muppets.

Grade: A+


  • Winning today’s post are “One in Love with Amy” by Frank Sinatra, “Amie” by Pure Prairie League, and “Amie” by Damien Rice. Two out of the three of those, I’m head-over-heels for. I’m better with today’s choices than yesterday’s.
  • Losing today’s post are “Amy’s Back in Austin” by A Country Singer with a Very Impressive Mullet; “Amy’s Song,” by Some Band I’d Have Been Happy to Never Have Heard of Had I Not Done This Post, and “Amy” by The Man Who Wrote and Performed Music for Only Serial Killers.
  • If you are planning on wooing me, I’d bookmark this post for future consideration.

There we have it! That’s a lot of Amy songs. Some might say TOO many. Not me. Because I’m self-centered, you see. (What? I’d think as long as you can admit it, it’s ok, right? Right.)

About lucysfootball

I'm not the girl with the most cake. Someday. SOMEDAY. View all posts by lucysfootball

22 responses to “The Agony and The Ecstasy of Having a Very Popular Name, Part Two

  • cynthiaw

    A. I’m glad that you like Amie by Pure Prairie League because, if we ever meet, it’s the song most likely to come busting out whenever I see you.

    B. Come to Austin! I love Austin and will totally meet you there and we can have adventures – I’ll even take you to Frank’s and you can try their chocolate-covered bacon or bacon chocolate chip cookie, or both! There are a lot of weird things to take pictures of in Austin, too. We can even egg Rick Perry’s house.


    • lucysfootball

      Hee! I will be happy to meet you if you’re singing my song. It would make me grin!

      I would eat ALL the chocolate-bacon things!!! I approve of Austin. I’ve heard such great things. (Why does Rick Perry live there? Isn’t Austin the center of artsiness and weirdness and liberalness for the state? I’d think he’d want to live somewhere less progressive.)


      • cynthiaw

        I’m sure that he’ll move back to his lair once he isn’t our governor anymore. Right now, he has to live there because that’s the state capital. I’m sure that Austin’s weirdness annoys him – which makes me happy. Not as happy as I’ll be when he isn’t our governor anymore, but happy nonetheless.


        • lucysfootball

          Ah, I didn’t even think of that. (Our governor doesn’t live here, even though he has a mansion here. It’s not a rule for us. I believe he lives in NYC and didn’t want to move. I don’t blame him – it’s a great place to live. He spends a lot of time here, though.)

          I imagine Austin makes him all kinds of stabby. That makes me happy, too.


          • cynthiaw

            I don’t know that it’s a rule, but the Governor’s mansion is in Austin. Someone tried to burn it down and they’ve been restoring it – I don’t know if they’re done or not. I do know that the taxpayers have been paying a boatload of rent for Rick and his family to live in a real nice house while the restoration goes on. He should have to stay in a condo or something.

            In fact, since the legislature only meets every other year, I don’t even know how much time he spends in Austin – probably, as little as possible. Hopefully, he’ll go crawl under a rock somewhere.


  • mfennvt

    I love Pure Prairie League, too. One of those childhood songs (I was 11 when it came out) that holds up well. :)


  • aliceatwonderland

    Oooh, that’s the song, Amieeeeeeeeeee, whatchu wanna do, Amieeeeeeeee why’d I spell the name so dumb, Amieeeeeeee – yeah I love that song and can sing it dozens of times even though I mostly only know the chorus. Amyyyyyyyyyy. That’s, like, the normal spelling. I have never known an Amy spelled that way. Ami, Aimee (if you’re going for snooty French), but not Amie. But I like the song even with the twanginess, cause, Amy.

    My mother loved “Once in Love with Amy”, but sung by someone else, I forget who. Maybe it was Bobby Darin, who had an Amy song last time, right? My husband actually dated two girls named Amy briefly before we met. He had to find the right one. I will have to listen to the other ones later, after work. I am especially eager to hear the serial killer one.

    Here’s another question – why have Amy in the title but not in the song? There’s another one of those, a John Denver one, that’s somebody’s song, but no one remembers that title because he never uses the girls’ name in the song. Grrr.


    • lucysfootball

      I don’t love that Amie-spelling, either. It’s how you spell friend in French. It’s like they didn’t even TRY to make it a name.

      I like that your husband cycled through Amys. I’m glad he found a keeper. Who knows what would have happened had he kept going? Totally a creepy Amy. For sure.

      I don’t like when they put someone’s name in the title, but not the lyrics. It’s like, “I wrote you a song! But once you’re gone, I could use it to woo any other chick by not telling them what the title is!” Lame.

      “Annie’s Song.” Oh, John Denver. You make my ears bleed with your easy-listening-osity.


  • Mer

    Ok, I have to be a weirdo and defend Paul Petersen (the man, not the song) with my VH1 knowledge. he was probably one of the first teen idols playing the son on the Donna Reed show. His experiences were so horrible that once he survived and became an adult, he has dedicated his life to protecting the rights of child actors. He was probably forced to make that bizarre album.
    Oh, Frank Sinatra,lovely as always.


    • lucysfootball

      You are never a weirdo. I love that you know that! And that makes sense. Those overproduced teen albums are ALWAYS terrible. Now I feel bad for him.

      Sorry, Paul Petersen! I no longer blame you for that serial-killery song!


  • becomingcliche

    I like Switchfoot, but I don’t think I’ve ever heard the song. I am in a hotel room with three boys at the moment watching Cartoon Network. Listening to songs is not an option today. Tomorrow, though…


  • poetlandia

    I like Pure Prarie League. I have a Sinatra story that I will tell if we ever meet in person. Also, I generally like the name Amy.

    I think that’s all.


    • lucysfootball

      Ooh, I like Sinatra stories! I hope it’s not him being mobstery. I know he was kind of a jerk, but that VOICE. Whoo!

      I think the name Amy is fine for people who are Amy-like, but I don’t see myself as Amy-like. It’s so CHEERFUL! I think I might be a Maude.


      • poetlandia

        Oh no, this is a nice story. I don’t know anything about mobsters. (And I like it that way.) He’s a sweet guy in this story, and it’s a first hand story rather than something that happened to someone else, so there you have it.

        Maybe you need to write a dystopian novel and call the lead character Amy and have her be morose. ;) Maude reminds me of the show Maude. And also of Harold and Maude. (One of my favourite movies of all time.)


        • lucysfootball

          I’m the only person in the whole world who doesn’t like “Harold and Maude.” It makes people very upset when I admit that. I’m willing to admit there’s something wrong with me; there must be, since everyone else is so charmed by it.

          Ooh, a morose Amy is a thing that’s never been before SEEN in literature! I like that very much! I also like that there’s a good story about Sinatra out there. Because there are so many “he was a self-involved jerk who hated women!” stories, and they make me sad.


          • poetlandia

            Well, Harold and Maude. It’s something of an acquired taste. For me, anyway.

            I really like the idea of morose Amy. Hmmmm. I’m working on a dystopian novel. If we both did one and had a lead named Amy ….


            • lucysfootball

              Oh, morose Amy is good in theory, but in real life, she’s terribly insufferable. She cries a lot and sighs and refuses to talk about what’s bothering her. It’s not a good time.

              I don’t know that I know anyone who doesn’t love “Harold and Maude!” I think I’m just broken. It was a long time ago I watched it, but I disliked it so violently that I can’t make myself watch it again, no matter how much I reason with myself I should.


%d bloggers like this: